Published adventures don’t know your PCs, so they have to go generic. But you should never be satisfied with that.
Published adventures don’t know your PCs, so they have to go generic. But you should never be satisfied with that.
Is a +1 sword magical? Technically, yes. But does it feel like magic? Probably not.
So now you have a stack of notes about the city. How do you actually use them during play?
The key is that virtually all actions in the city boil down to either finding information or going to a location.
For finding information, check out Rulings in Practice: Gathering Information for an in-depth look. Finding the information will almost always involve going somewhere. Often the information the PCs are looking for will be (either directly or indirectly) a location, too – a service they need, a resource, the place where their enemy is hiding out, etc.
Once the PCs are heading to a location, look at your notes for the district they’re going to. Then:
Advanced Technique: Make the encounter check first. If an encounter is indicated, you can then choose to frame the encounter at either the landmark or the destination itself. It’s a convenient way of adding context to procedurally generated content, and can also be a great way of adding unexpected complications to whatever location the PCs are heading to.
And that’s all it takes.
The districts and landmarks weave together the geographical fabric of the city. The encounters provide a low-level of activity not directly connected to the PCs or what they’re immediately engaged with, creating the sensation that the city is in constant motion.
By the same token, this doesn’t need to be a straitjacket. Maybe you mention two or three landmarks instead of just one. Maybe you complicate things by checking for encounters in each district the PCs pass through. Or, conversely, once you’ve established the life of the city as a pervasive presence at the table, you may find that effective pacing demands fast-forwarding past an encounter and cutting straight to the action.
Follow this procedure rigorously for a couple or three sessions to make sure you’ve really internalized it, but then do what feels right, knowing that you can always return to this procedure as a safe and effective foundation.
INTRODUCING THE CITY
Now that we’ve established our basic procedure, let’s take a closer look at our first session: How do we go about introducing a city to the players?
If one or more of the PCs live in the city or are otherwise familiar with it, particularly if it’s going to be the focal setting of the entire campaign, I will prep a short player briefing to orient them. This will include:
Give this briefing to the players before or during Session 0 so that it can inform character creation.
As with most such handouts, five pages is probably the longest you’d want to make this. Any longer and, in my experience, most players won’t actually process the information. (Paradoxically, the more information you try to cram into the handout, the less information about the city the players will actually take away from it.)
It may also be useful to note that this player briefing largely mirrors the material you’ve prepped for yourself. If you’re doing minimal prep yourself, you can often just strip out the random encounter tables and be good to go.
But what about the adventurer at the gate scenario, where a PC is coming to the city for the first time?
Generally, I will still give them the map. Even if the PCs technically wouldn’t have one, it’s just too useful as an easy point of common reference at the table. (I will often print out poster-size version of the map and hang them on the wall of the gaming room, using a laser point to indicate locations.)
Advanced Technique: If you’d rather run a streetcrawl until the PCs have taken action to orient themselves within the city (which might be literally obtaining a diegetic map, but could also simply be sufficiently exploring the city, closely questioning a local, visiting every district, or something else along those lines), that can be a very immersive technique. In a peaceful city, however, you may not find that the streetcrawl to be particularly compelling.
At this point, focus on the players’ goals, but use those goals as a vector for the player briefing.
For example, if the players say that they’re going to spend a day or two getting to know the city, that’s super simple: You can just give them the player briefing.
But maybe they say something like, “Let’s find an inn.”
Depending on what their goal is, you might call for some kind of skill check to see if they can find it – Streetwise, Charisma (Investigation), Library Use, something like that.
Advanced Technique: Even if they’ll definitely find the thing they’re looking for, you might still call for the skill check and use fail forward techniques to make the check meaningful. Maybe on a success they can find a really good deal and/or on a failure they get marked as rubes by pickpockets.
If it’s a common service, present them with the multiple options you prepped earlier. (High-, middle-, and low-class for hotels, for example). Specifically call out the different districts these services are in. If they went looking for a weapons shop, you might say, “There’s an elven bowyer in Emerald Hill or dwarven crafters in the Guildsman District.” You’re not just saying, “These districts exist.” You’re inviting the players to make a choice based on these districts. That’s significant. The districts are now an active part of the players’ thinking about the setting. The more they do that, the more the city comes alive in their imagination.
As this point, the PCs are going to pick a location to go to – either a common service they’ve selected or some specific location that brought them to town in the first place (e.g., the tower of the High Mage Ghulak). This is simple: Just use the urban procedure we detailed above… but with one important addition!
For the district of the location they choose, include the description of the district from the player briefing. You can probably work these two or three sentences into the description of their journey to the inn or tower or whatever.
As the players work their way through their shopping list (or whatever brought them to the city), you’ll be organically building up their understanding of the city over time. The scenic encounters, landmarks, and the locations found in the adventure scenarios you’re running will gradually draw them further and further into the setting, resulting in them setting goals that are increasingly specific (“let’s find the leader of the Red Bandit pickpockets who tried to rob us” or “that abandoned lighthouse looks cool, let’s go check it out”).
In play, this might look something like this:
And so forth.
Once the players are familiar with a district, of course, you can obviously stop briefing them on the district. At this point, the newcomers have acclimated to the city and you simplify back into the standard urban procedure.
OPTION: BACKGROUND EVENTS
A final option you can add to your cities to give them even greater depth are background events.
These are events running in parallel with the campaign, but which don’t directly affect the PCs. They include stuff like:
They appear as newspaper headlines or as random gossip when the PCs are chatting with an NPC. Layering these into your urban-based campaign is a great way of adding even more depth to the city.
Of particular note here are factions, which are often a part of many urban campaigns. Describing the offscreen actions of these factions through background events weaves them into the life of the city, making them a pervasive part of the environment and enhancing the actions directly affecting the PCs as part of the campaign by making the factions vast in their scope.
FURTHER READING
Thinking About Urbancrawls
Ptolus: In the Shadow of the Spire
Dragon Heist: The Alexandrian Remix
You know that saying that “there are eight million stories in the naked city?”
That’s 100% true. There’s no easy way to narrow down what an urban campaign “should” be, because it CAN be an infinite number of things. You might have:
And so forth.
But no matter what campaign structure I’m using, and regardless of whether I’m running Waterdeep, Dweredell, Hong Kong, or Los Angeles, there are a few techniques I’ve learned that can help bring the city to vivid life.
WHAT TO PREP
This guide assumes that the city is either the setting for the entire campaign or, at the very least, a place that the PCs are going to be exploring for awhile. If the PCs are just visiting the city (flying in for a single adventure, for example), you may still find some of this material useful, but you’ll want to scale it down (and almost certainly focus your prep around what you know the PCs will be doing there).
I’m also assuming that we’re talking about an actual city. For smaller communities – villages, remote space stations, etc. – some of these techniques may, once again, be useful in a stripped-down state. But, in my experience, they’re actually very distinct (and probably merit their own discussion at some point).
With that in mind, here’s what you want to prep for a city setting.
First, the map. If it’s a city in the real world, track down a street map. Google Maps or Apple Maps will be invaluable resources, but I wouldn’t recommend relying on them as your primary map. You really want something that lets you come to grips with the city in its totality.
If it’s a city you’re creating, you’ll obviously need to draw the map. (Or generate one. The tools for this are getting better all the time.) Don’t feel like you need to detail every single street or building. But you will want to break the city down into districts and to know the major routes that connect those districts.
Design Tip: When thinking about routes, it can be easy to default to “road.” But that’s often not the case, and a city’s unique character can be defined by its transportation: The London Underground. The Venetian canals. New York ferries.
Similarly, emphasize the fantastic nature of your speculative settings with fabulist transportation routes: Zeppelin towers. Etheric railways. Fairy roads.
Second, on that note, you want to break the city down into neighborhoods/districts. I find the sweet spot for a new city to be somewhere between six and twelve. You want enough divisions to give the city texture – so that being in Oldtown feels different than being in South Market or the Docks – but not so many that either you or the players are overwhelmed.
(Over time, for larger cities, you may discover that you want to create sub-districts within these broader areas, particularly in regions of the city where the PCs spend a lot of time. For example, in a New York City campaign you might start with the five boroughs – Manhattan, the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens, and Staten Island – plus the Gold Coast in Jersey. Later, you might break Manhattan into Harlem, the Upper East Side, Lower East Side, etc. And maybe after that, if you’re feeling particularly ambitious, you’d want to track even finer distinctions in the Lower East Side like the East Village, Chinatown, Alphabet City, etc. Even when you’ve reached the point where, for example, you’ve got Manhattan split up into forty-two separate neighborhoods, you’ll still want to keep the high-level districts distinct in your mind and the minds of your players. They’ll remain useful tools.)
For each district, you’ll want to describe its general character. This can be as simple as a couple of sentences, but you can dive into more detail like:
In addition to this general description, you will want a specific list of landmarks in the district. You might be able to get away with just one, but you’ll probably want to have at least three per district.
Sometimes when we talk about “landmarks” we get trapped thinking strictly about statues or big, famous buildings. But for our purposes this is really just “things in the district.” So if you put the Lion’s Purr tavern in a district, you can also add it to the landmarks list.
If your city becomes detailed enough, you may want to break out a separate list of “major landmarks” for each district for the sake of utility, but even this list will likely be (and arguably should be) esoteric, focusing on the sites that have become relevant to you, your players, and the campaign as much as the big stuff that would make a generic tourist’s guide.
For each district you’re also going to want scenic encounters. These might be procedural encounters (i.e., random encounters) or they might be handcrafted (in which case you’ll need to periodically restock them as they get used up).
The key thing that makes the urban environment feel distinct from other adventure locales is the constant activity. You want the players to feel like there’s stuff happening all the time and just out of sight. As we’ll see, this is the primary function of these scenic encounters. In addition, we distinguish them by district because we want the different areas of town to feel distinct: The stuff that happens in Oldtown is, once again, different than what you see on the streets of South Market.
A few practical tips for prepping these encounters without getting overwhelmed:
The last thing you’ll want to prep for the city is a list of services.
Exactly which services you’ll want to list is going to be very dependent on the campaign you’re prepping. If the PCs are wandering adventurers coming to the city for the first time, for example, you’ll likely want to have a list of inns. If the PCs live in the city, on the other hand, maybe that’s not so important.
Some common categories here, however, include:
Before you get lost in the weeds here, it’s important to remember that you’re not trying to list every single example of each service in the city. In many cases, you probably can’t. Take Galveston, TX, for example, a modest town with a population of 50,000. It has dozens of hotels and more than a hundred bars. Even if you wanted to prep all those options, would it really be useful at the table?
What is useful at the table is having enough options so that the players can make a meaningful choice. For example, in the Eternal Lies campaign, the PCs visit a number of cities around the world. For each city, I prepped three hotels: A high-class, middle-class, and low-class option. This both mirrored the likely criteria the players would be using to decide on their accommodations and tied into a meaningful choice within the structure the campaign (i.e., how the investigators were spending their limited pool of resources in each city.)
You can see what that prep looked like here.
(This class-based division can be a useful one for a number of different services: Are you going to a classy restaurant or a dive bar? A flea market in Chinatown or a swanky store on Fifth Avenue? But you may find other criteria are more relevant to your campaign. Prep accordingly.)
Remember to cross-reference these services into the district listings as landmarks (either minor or major).
At this point you might be asking yourself: Do I really need to prep all this stuff? Can I just improvise it instead?
Sure.
But make sure you take notes. A defining aspect of the urban environment is its persistency. You build the city up in the players’ imagination over time by showing them the same locations and geography again and again and again: You’re going down Tavern Row or Chicago Avenue. On the way to the museum, you pass that weird Italian-Korean fusion restaurant where you first met Felicia. On the way back to your hotel, you’re near the statue of George Washington when the thunderstorm breaks and rain begins pouring down.
And as you’re taking these notes, you’ll find this structure – map, district, landmarks, services, etc. – useful for organizing them and using them. No matter how much or how little you prep to begin with, in fact, your notes on the city will continue to expand and grow as you play – adding new locations through both adventure prep and improvisation.
Aggah-Shan’s guards regularly patrol this level. There are 10 guards in total.
AGGAH-SHAN’S GUARD
Medium undead, lawful evil
Armor Class 16 (natural)
Hit Points 112 (15d8+45)
Speed 30 ft.
STR 18 (+4), DEX 15 (+2), CON 16 (+3), INT 10 (+0), WIS 15 (+2), CHA 12 (+1)
Saving Throws Str +7, Dex +5, Con +6
Skills Athletics +10, Intimidation +5
Damage Immunities poison
Condition Immunities poisoned, exhaustion
Senses darkvision 60 ft., passive Perception 12
Languages Giant
Challenge 5 (1,800 XP)
Slavish. The guard has advantage on saving throws against being frightened, charmed, or turned.
ACTIONS
Multiattack. The guard makes three attacks with its necromantic mace.
Necromantic Mace. Melee Weapon Attack: +7 to hit, reach 5 ft, one target. Hit: 8 (1d6+4) bludgeoning damage and 7 (2d6) necrotic damage
Aggah-Shan’s guard are undead warriors, wrapped in brown funerary linens and wearing crimson-red Anubian helms. Through the jackal’s mouth their skull can be seen, with red flames in their eyesockets. Each wields a top-heavy mace which crackles with purplish necrotic energy. They carry large, copper shields in the shape of a beetle’s wings.
AREA 16 – THE OTHER THRONE OF IRON
A throne of black iron and gray stone sits in the middle of a blue-tiled room. The ceiling is painted with roiling flames.
TELEPORTATION THRONES: Characters using the throne in Area 12 to teleport arrive on the identical throne in this area, and vice versa.
SECRET DOOR: DC 30 Intelligence (Investigation) check to detect. The door is not trapped, but opening it releases the permanent wail of the banshee in Area 23 so that it can also be heard by characters in Area 16.
AREA 17 – THE HALL OF SCENTED SMOKES
A dozen magical braziers line the length of this hall. Lighting any one of them causes all of them to alight, filling the room with colorful smokes carrying pleasant scents.
AREA 18 – LEY-LACED STATUE
A classical statue of a bare-chested archer bending his bow back, his foot placed upon the breast of a maiden who lies nude at his feet. Thick, blue-black veins run through the marble.
INTELLIGENCE (ARCANA) – DC 16: The statue is carved from ley-laced marble. This statue acts as a pearl of power that can be used up to four times per day. It is currently keyed to an adamantine arrow which fits into the archer’s bow (and is currently either in Area 15 or carried by Aggah-Shan).
LEY-LACED MARBLE
Ley-laced marble is a naturally occurring stone. During the metamorphic processes which form the marble, ley-energy permeates the impurities lacing the sedimentary rocks. The resulting marble (which is usually found on or near ley lines) is possessed of properties similar to a pearl of power. (In fact, it’s hypothesized that pearls of power were created by reverse-engineering ley-laced marble.)
Unlike pearls of power, however, ley-laced marble is not particularly efficient in its retention of magical energy. In addition to being difficult to excavate from the ground, ley-laced marble must be maintained in such large chunks in order to maintain its properties that it is rarely if ever portable in any true sense of the word.
However, rites have been perfected which allow a piece of ley-laced marble to be keyed to a specific object. Anyone carrying the keyed object can access the powers of the ley-laced marble at a distance of 1 mile per character level.
AREA 19 – HALL OF GILDED SKULLS
Six skulls gilded in gold sit on cushions placed atop marble pillars. Two pillars stand empty.
SKULLS: Each skull has a named burned into its dome — Verana, Elmchaea, Enel, Siust, Atath, and Mosdyna.
DM Background: These skulls belonged to Aggah-Shan’s enemies.
AREA 20 – AGGAH-SHAN’S LIBRARY
Most of the volumes in this library reveal a mind consumed with a strange, compulsive disorder: Gambling odds calculated, recalculated, and then calculated again. Written out at great length in varied tabular arrangements — vast expanses of endless tabulated data.
AGGAH-SHAN’S SPELLBOOK: But this library is also home to Aggah-Shan’s Spellbook. The book is designed to be opened by placing Aggah-Shan’s bony finger into the skull-faced keyhole on the cover. If any other finger is placed in that keyhole or if someone attempts to force the book open, it triggers a prismatic spray trap (DC 14 Intelligence (Investigation) to detect; DC 14 Dexterity (Thieves’ Tools) to disable; DC 20 Dexterity saving throw if triggered).
BOOK OF MRATHRACH: The library also contains the Book of Mrathrach (a chaos lorebook).
BOOK OF MRATHRACH
In those days when the Masters of Chaos still stirred and the echoes of their spirits were manifest within the Temples of the Screaming Dead tended by the midnight priests of the Earthbound Demons, there walked upon this earth the Man who would have made demons of all men; who would have immanentized the mortal flesh in eschatonic blood.
This book tells the bloody tale of Mrathrach. It purports to be a reconstruction of an ancient verse epic, although the passages of verse preserved within its pages are broken and irregular (although somehow beating with a primal pulse when read aloud).
Mrathrach was a warlord in the demon armies which “fought black-backed against that oily light of piety’s tyrannicies.” His faith to his master, “the Duke Gellasatrac,” is lauded and entire passages are given over to describing the great deeds of martial honor and the bloody human sacrifices he offered to Gellasatrac’s glory.
But when the war turns against the demon armies, the poem becomes an elegiacal transformation of the strife of conflicted duty. In the end, it describes how Mrathrach agreed to betray Gellasatrac to “the greater glory of the Masters and the presecient schismed schemes of the Shallamoth.”
And he drank of the Black Blood, the Holy Gift of Gellasatrac. So Mrathrach became the First of the Vested — vested in the trust of his masters; vested in their power; vested in their fate. The first quenching by which the bands of power would be forged.
AGGAH-SHAN’S SPELLBOOK
Spells marked with * are from the Ptolus sourcebook.
CANTRIPS: chill touch, shocking grasp
1st LEVEL: burning hands, charm person, color spray, detect chaositech*, detect evil and good, dissonant whispers, endure elements, expeditious retreat, feather fall, fog cloud, grease, jump, mage armor, magic missile, shield, silent image, sleep, Tenser’s floating disk, unseen servant
2nd LEVEL: aid from the future*, alter self, arcane lock, blindness/deafness, blur, darkvision, enlarge/reduce, flaming sphere, invisibility, levitate, mirror image, ray of enfeeblement, rope trick, see invisibility, spider climb, suggestion
3rd LEVEL: blink, conjure animals, fly, gaseous form, haste, hold person, hypnotic pattern, Leomund’s tiny hut, lightning bolt, magic circle, slow, tongues
4th LEVEL: banishment, confusion, conjure minor elementals, polymorph, stoneshape, stoneskin, wall of fire
5th LEVEL: animate necrosis*, animate objects, cloudkill, contact other plane, divinatory expungement*, enervation, mislead, wall of stone
6th LEVEL: chain lightning, create undead, disintegrate, eyebite, flesh to stone, move earth, teleport trace
7th LEVEL: month of Vallis*, prismatic spray, teleport
AREA 21 – AGGAH-SHAN’S GUARD
1d8+2 of Aggah-Shan’s necromantic guards can be found here. (There are 10 total. The others are patrolling this level, as described above.)
AREA 22 – THE FALSE PHYLACTERY
BATH: The southern end of this chamber is a bath made of black marble with two silver dragon heads looking out over the room.
PRISMATIC CUBE: Levitating in the center of the room is a set of double-layered prismatic wall spells forming a cube.
FALSE PHYLACTERY: Within the prismatic cube is a hollow mithril statue in the shape of a man lying on a cushion of blue velvet. A heart-shaped trapdoor on the statue’s chest can be opened, revealing adamantine wires which have been welded to various points within the statue and then bound together into a very specific and cleverly-woven knot. The statue has an arcanist’s magic aura placed upon it to make it appear to be a lich’s phylactery (but it is not).
AREA 23 – TRAPPED HALL
Beyond the secret door in Area 16, a short hallway leads to Area 24.
WAIL OF THE BANSHEE: This area is filled with a permanent wail of the banshee. The wail has no effect on constructs or undead. All other creatures who hear the wail are afflicted by a powerful death magic and must succeed on a DC 25 Constitution saving throw. On a failure, a creature with less than 100 hit points instantly drops to 0 hit points. Creatures not reduced to 0 hit points instead stuffer 9d8+50 necrotic damage (or half damage on a successful save).
TRAP – CRUSHING WALL: In addition to the wail, this area also has a pressure plate in front of the door to Area 24) that triggers a crushing wall trap (affecting everyone in the hall).
DOOR TO AREA 24: The door is also trapped. Anyone touching the door triggers an incendiary cloud (that lasts for 1 minute, moving into Area 16).
AREA 24 – TRUE PHYLACTERY
PRISMATIC CUBE: Levitating in the center of this room is a set of double-layered prismatic wall spells forming a prismatic cube. Inside the cube if a forcecage.
TRUE PHYLACTERY: Within the forcecage is a sphere of adamantine (4-in. thick). Within the sphere are three humanoid figures of taurum (the true gold which makes common gold naught but a bauble), each inscribed with a single rune upon its chest.
Destroying the figurines destroys Aggah-Shan’s phylactery.