Eternal Lies is an amazing campaign written for Trail of Cthulhu by Will Hindmarch, Jeff Tidball, and Jeremy Keller.
The basic conceit of the campaign is that a decade ago a band of occult investigators battled against the summoning of an ancient and monstrous evil… and failed. Now the PCs need to piece together what went wrong and try to salvage whatever they can. It was explicitly designed to be a spiritual successor to the Masks of Nyarlathotep and, like that classic campaign, features a freewheeling, international investigation of epic scope.
Long-time readers of the site may recall that I consider Masks of Nyarlathotep to be one of the best RPG campaigns ever published, and that it also provided the core concept for both the Three Clue Rule and Node-Based Scenario Design. Despite the incredibly high esteem in which I hold the Masks of Nyarlathotep, however, I’m of the opinion that Eternal Lies is even better.
It’s probably unsurprising, therefore, that a few months back I started prepping to run Eternal Lies. As is often the case, however, I got a trifle ambitious with my plans. The result was a large expansion (and a slight revamping) of the entire campaign, and over the next couple or three weeks I’d like to share with you the material I developed in the form of the Alexandrian Remix of Eternal Lies.
SPOILER WARNING
This should probably go without saying, but from this point forward there will be huge spoilers for Eternal Lies. Literally stuff that will spoil the entire campaign for you.
As a particular warning for players in my extended gaming network: I’m planning to run this campaign again at some point in the (probably near) future. If you’d like to be able to actually play the campaign, I’m afraid you’re going to have to tune out of my website for a little while.
DESIGN NOTES
There are several core elements which make up the remix, and I think the material will be a little clearer if I explain its structure.
First, there are LOCATION DIORAMAS. The campaign, as published, is broken up across nine distinct locations. For each of these locations I prepped a diorama which could be hung on the wall near the gaming table. The centerpiece of each diorama was a large, poster-sized map. This was accompanied by a variety of photos, drawings, period advertisements, and the like. The idea was to provide a rich, visual reference for the players.
The dioramas were also intended to be persistent and interactive. As the PCs gathered clues and other materials in each location, they could be added to the dioramas. And as the PCs moved to each new location, the dioramas from the previous locations would remain. Over the course of the campaign, the gaming area would become immersed in the 1930s through a slow, inevitable, kudzu-like growth.
Second, there are PROP PACKETS. These are, again, grouped by location. I used a handful of physical props which, in the absence of 3D printing, I’m unable to share with you, but most of the materials are paper props of various kinds.
- For newspaper articles, I printed them on sheets of 8.5” x 11” newsprint.
- Most of the photos are designed to be printed directly onto 4” x 6” photo paper.
- Larger photos are designed for 8.5” x 11” photo paper. (In some cases, multiple images are arranged so that they can be printed on a single sheet and cut out.)
- For telegrams, I found that simply printing them on yellow paper was extremely effective.
- For the record album, I have included an MP3 audio file and also a CD label that can be printed using the Neato CD labels. (The CD is obviously anachronistic, but the ability to actually take the prop and play it is pretty awesome.)
Most of these props are original (albeit often sourced from period photographs and the like). But several of the props were originally developed by and shared by others on Yog-Sothoth.com. I’m including my copies here because most of them have been altered or repurposed to fit into the rest of my campaign schema, but if you end up continuing to develop Eternal Lies material for your own tables I heartily encourage you to pop over to Yog-Sothoth and share your work with the larger community.
Third, there are my CAMPAIGN NOTES. As with the dioramas and prop packets, these are broken down by location. They serve as a quick reference for running the campaign, but obviously also contain all of the other alterations and additions I’ve made.
NODE STRUCTURE
One of my biggest goals with this remix was to enrich the node-based structure of the campaign.
As written, Eternal Lies has a fairly straight-forward structure: A short track of investigation takes you from New York to Savannah and then to a mansion in Los Angeles where you discover a book which contains clues pointing to four other locations scattered around the globe. While investigating those locations, you’ll discover additional clues which will combine to form a “final 
revelation” pointing you towards the conclusion of the campaign.
I liked the open-ended, go wherever you want structure. What I didn’t like was the book. First, it was a single point of failure: If the PCs don’t find the book, the rest of the campaign doesn’t happen. Second, it feels a little too on-the-nose in the metagame: It felt like the GM saying, “Here’s your menu for the campaign. Please make your next selection.”
I wanted something a little more organic. I wanted things to feel messy and real. I wanted to give the players a greater sense of charting their own course, instead of just picking from a menu of three options. And I wanted the choice of sequence to have a more meaningful impact on how the investigation played out.
First, I significantly decreased the importance of the book and liberally spread clues pointing to the other cult locations throughout the Los Angeles investigation. I also mixed things up by adding additional clues to both the New York and Savannah investigations: It’s now possible to go from New York directly to Los Angeles, for example. Or to follow a lead from Savannah and go directly to Bangkok.
Second, I radically increased the cross-pollination of clues between locations. For example, in the original campaign the only “access point” to Bangkok was the book in Los Angeles. In the remix campaign, investigators can be pointed towards Bangkok from Savannah, Malta, Mexico City, and Axum.
So if the investigators, for example, take the first clue they find in Los Angeles and skedaddle before completing the rest of their investigation there, everything will be just fine: Wherever they’re going, they should be able to dig up more clues to keep their investigation alive. (In a worst case scenario, of course, they might find themselves doubling back to Los Angeles.)
THE FINAL REVELATIONS
The biggest weakness in Eternal Lies are two revelations that the PCs have to make near the end of the campaign. The first of these is the revelation that the Devouring Mountain, where the ultimate villain of the campaign is located, is Mt. Kailash in Thibet. In the campaign as written, this revelation is theoretically split into three clues:
- A map in Bangkok showing that the villain is located at Mt. Kailash.
- A clue in Malta that the villain can only be reached at Mt. Kailash during a certain time of the month.
- A clue in Mexico City that reveals that Mt. Kailash is the Devouring Mountain.
I say “theoretically split” because it’s pretty obvious that once you get a map pointing you directly at the location, you can pretty much brute force the rest of the problem (which causes the entire campaign to short circuit).
To fix this, it has been recommended that the map in Bangkok is in a huge stack of papers and only becomes notable once the PCs discover the clue in Mexico City. This is unsatisfying, however, because it creates a dynamic where the penultimate conclusion of the campaign isn’t the result of the players solving a mystery, it’s just the GM telling them where to go next.
To make matters even worse, Eternal Lies then immediately repeats this mistake. At the conclusion of the events at Mt. Kailash, the GM is supposed to once again say, “Oh, yeah. Your characters now remember a piece of paper I never told you about that tells you what to do next.”
It’s as if you were playing a traditional murder mystery and, at the end of the scenario, the GM said, “Oh, yeah. Your character remembers seeing a clue I didn’t tell you about several weeks ago. Tom’s the murderer.”
To which I say: Bah! Humbug!
So as part of the Alexandrian Remix, these final two revelations have been significantly restructured.
First, the MT. KAILASH REVELATION consists of three clues:
- Sirikhan mounted unsuccessful expeditions to several locations searching for the Maw of the Mouth, including Mt. Kailash. (Clues to this effect are primarily found in Bangkok.)
- The Maw of the Mouth lies within the Devouring Mountain. (Clues to this effect are primarily found in Mexico City.)
- The Rift of the Maw opens only on the night of a New Moon beneath a clear sky. (Clues to this effect are primarily found in Malta.)
So in Bangkok the PCs will essentially gain a big list of location names, with no way to distinguish which location is the one they want. (Note that the only mountain in the list is Mt. Kailash.) In Mexico City they’ll be told that they’re looking for a mountain. And in Malta they’ll be told when they need to be there (which also explains why Savitree failed). It doesn’t matter which order they find these clues in, they won’t be able to piece the whole thing together unless they have all three.
Second, the REVELATION OF THE APOCALYPSE was trickier to solve. The method I eventually adopted was to NOT provide clues that allow the PCs to “solve” the mystery. Instead, I designed four key concepts:
- Great power requires great sacrifice.
- Echavarria’s ritual had two layers / two purposes.
- Edgar Job played a key role in Echavarria’s ritual, but no one knows what it was.
- Azathoth was the true focus of Echavarria’s interest.
And then I layered material supporting these concepts throughout the campaign. I can then pull whatever subset of material they discovered to form the final, spiteful vision sent to them at Mt. Kailash. For example: “Edgar Jobs dragging a cigarette and telling you he was Chosen by Echavarria in 1924. The summoning of the Liar From Beyond as only one part of the ritual. Montgomery Donovan sacrificing his wife because he knew it was necessary to sacrifice great things to achieve great power. What greater sacrifice could there be then a god summoned from beyond the Great Wall of Glaaki? And what greater power than the destructive gaze of Azathoth!”
The idea is that, at least thematically, the answer was in front of them the entire time (instead of being delivered from out of the blue). The actual solution to the problem has also been tweaked, so even after they get this revelation, they’ll still need to figure out what to actually do about it.
NEW LOCATIONS
Those already familiar with the campaign will also notice that there are two completely new locations in the Alexander Remix: The Severn Valley and Axum. Both of these arose through actual play, and I’ll be discussing the role they play in more detail as they actually get presented.
CHANGE OF DATE
A final significant change I made to the campaign was the date: As published, Eternal Lies begins in 1937, thirteen years after the original ritual was performed in 1924.
I suspect, however, that the campaign was originally supposed to start in 1934 and the decision to move it to 1937 was made rather late in the design process (for reasons that aren’t entirely clear to me). There are a number of subtle hints to this effect in the text, but the big one is that one section of the campaign is set during the Abyssinia Crisis, which started in 1934 and was concluded by May 1936.
Rather than try to completely rework the Ethiopia material, I decided to simply crank the clock back. My version of the campaign begins in New York on October 31st, 1934.
THE ALEXANDRIAN REMIX
1.0 Maps and Campaign Props
1.1 New York
1.2 Savannah
1.3 Los Angeles
Books of the Los Angeles Cult – UCLA Lot
Books of the Los Angeles Cult – Echavarria’s Library
2.0 Act II – Floating Scenes
2.1 Bangkok
2.2.1 Severn Valley
2.2 Ethiopia
2.2.1 Obelisk of Axum
2.3 Malta
2.4 Mexico City
2.5 Yucatan
Addendum: Airports
Addendum: Hotels
Addendum: Newspapers
You may also find my System Cheat Sheet for Trail of Cthulhu useful.
Looks to be a very exciting period for the blog over the next few weeks.
As someone who has never played a Cthulhu style game (only Dark Heresy, D&D & Pathfinder) would this campaign be a good starting point?
If it matters, I have two players and we play online with the Roll20 virtual tabletop.
Oh good! You found out when the campaign was set. I was a bit surprised that they didn’t state it anywhere, like the campaign overview, for example. Little glitches like that plus the dreadful overwriting put me right off running the campaign, which is a shame as deep down it is quite good.
Jonathan, I wouldn’t suggest running a campaign of this scale as your first introduction to Cthulhu gaming as they can be quite a commitment in time if nothing else; you could be playing something like this for a year or two. Call of Cthulhu has some excellent starting adventures that can be played in a session or two; I don’t know about Trail of Cthulhu but it’s quite easy to convert CoC adventures over.
I would start with a few shorter adventures to get a feel for the style of game before moving on to something larger like Eternal Lies.
Like Kelvin, I’d recommend dipping your toes with a few one-shots. For example, I ran “The Murderer of Thomas Fell” to acclimate myself and my players to the system before diving in to Eternal Lies.
The overwriting isn’t as bad as a lot of recent adventure products, but I can sympathize with being put off by it in general. Despite being a big advocate of published adventures for years now, I’ve been gradually backing away from them because the prose has so often become bloated to the point of making the product unusable without a lot of redundant prep.
Where Eternal Lies does crack me up is the weak tea GMing advice that randomly shows up in the middle of the book. For example, on page 261: “Eternal Lies is performed on the soundstage of your imagination. It is not played out on location in Mexico City, 1937. When conjuring an imaginary Mexico City for your adaptation
of Eternal Lies, remember that your dramatic interpretation of Mexico City must, foremost, serve your story.” Once we’re 200+ pages into a campaign supplement (and at a point where you’ve probably run at least a dozen sessions of it), we can probably skip past the “it’s all in your imagination! don’t sweat the details!” stuff.
Thank you to you both, I will approach my group with The Murder of Thomas Fell and see how it goes.
I really want to try and engross my players into our Cthulhu games, as online player definitely doesn’t have the flavour of sitting around a table together. Yet the thought of sending my players props, like your invitations, is such a fantastic idea!
Will try not to derail your Eternal Lies posts further, as it’s unlikely we will play for months… but know that I’m following along, taking notes and grateful for your hard work.
Yes, this series may be the thing that gets me to give Eternal Lies another try, so I’m reading along with considerable interest.
Justin, just wanted to say that all your work is great! Already absorbing your Bangkok materials and figuring what to integrate into my campaign. My guys are just heading to Mexico City from LA and I’ve been turning the lack of clues in Bangkok over a bit in my mind. Love Savitree’s research and can’t wait to get it printed and mailed to my players! Thanks again.
Jeff
Hi Justin!
I really enjoy your blog (I’m a game master, game designer and patron of yours, as well :).
I am currently planning on having a shot on Eternal Lies with my group, but as we are based in Germany, I would like to have the campaign be in German.
In order to do that (and to be able to use your excellent ressources for the campaign without constantly jiggling the two languages), I would like to ask you if you could provide me with .doc files of the Campaign Notes and the System Cheat Sheet, so that I can easily translate them for my group without needing to worry about formatting them.
I don’t need the handouts though (they provide more flavor when they are kept in the original language of their respective setting), so you don’t need to trouble yourself there.
I would be more than happy to be able to use your campaign notes in a translated version, and of course I would provide them back to you so you can share them with other potential German readers if you want.
Please get back at me and tell me if this is anything you might see yourself doing.
I’m really looking forward to hearing from you!
Sincerely, Yours
Tim H.
Hi Justin,
thanks for all your work. We’re at the moment testing the Trail waters by doing a few Arkham Detective Tales while I read a few times through EL campaign. Really looking forward to running that. I think the campaign by itself is very promising, but the changes you made, plus all the work you put into creating the handouts lift the experience so much!
One quick question: I notice that the fonts used for Henslowes letters (1.1) and Henslowes notebook (1.2) aren’t the same.
Which font did you use for the letters? If at all possible, I’d like to make them identical.
Kind regards
Sven
[…] and hours just for reading through Eternal Lies, and even more for preparing them (and translating Justin Alexander’s Remix). This amount of preparation load is certainly not what I am aiming at. Imagine the workload if you […]
[…] Special thanks to my GM Justin Alexander, whose notes on Eternal Lies you can find here. […]
Is your expansion something that could be done if we’ve already run through Eternal Lies already?
The core of the campaign is still Tidball, Hindmarch, and Keller, so it won’t really work to run it for the same players again. But there a couple of significant chunks that could be split off:
– Severn Isle is pretty much a stand-alone scenario. All you’d need to provide an alternative hook into the scenario, which I discuss in moderate detail.
– Obelisk of Axum is also all original material, but lacks a strong conclusion if left standing on its own. I also discuss options for this, albeit in less detail.
Hi.
Amazing vault of priceless gems this thing… great job, and thanks for sharing!
Since I’m about to run this little number now and have skimmed the whole book and poured over some of the chapters.
So far I have not found anything on Echivarra’s early life before he became this occult leader and all. More specifically, when was he born? Is there anywhere in the campaign where his age matters? He should be at least 30 in 1924 in my opinion, but apart from that?
Thanks!
No information on Echavarria’s past life that I’m aware of. Like you, I’d assume early 30’s: He’s got some experience, but young enough to have the “charismatic cult leader that you want to have an orgy with” going for him.
Justin,
Just wanted you to know that I posted a big thank you over on Yog-Sothoth after just finishing up Eternal Lies a couple of days ago. Gave you mad props for your remix, which I liberally used! I did something different with your Severn Valley locale, involving the PCs playing the EBA, which worked well and I discuss over there. But, thanks again for your huge contributions to Eternal Lies!
Jeff…
Just wanted to how utterly, wonderfully insane I find this project. Not only in extrapolating the details, but also in how you approach the broader lines – it’s very instructive. Three thumbs up!
I continue to appreciate the kind comments on this. Thanks, Jeff. Thanks, Thomas.
Hi. Just to let you know. I ran the whole Eternal Lies campaign (It lasted for 2 years of real time). It was one of the best rpg campaigns I have ever run and I think a lot of it has to do with your great work: your handouts, dioramas, your discussions of the chapters and your changes to the story. I used so many of your ideas… (not all: no Severn Valley, no obelisk). We (my rpg group) owe you a big one. Thanks a lot!
So happy to hear you had a good time! Thanks for letting me know!
Hi Justin,
My group are part of the way through running Eternal Lies and liberally using your remix to give it added flavour. The work you have done is fantastic, indeed I thought you might get a tickle out of knowing they have spent so long chasing up all the impressive leads and side stories in the Severn Valley that I have really struggled to get them back on track! We’re almost year of real world time through and they have been to Savannah, LA, Bangkok and now Severn Valley. One Investigator fed to the Mouth in Bangkok after going full crazy, necking a vial of nectar and going toe to toe with Thawi. Epic death.
I will update later but I have a question. As things stand, they may end up heading to Axum after the Abyssinia Crisis is finished, do you have any advice about altering the material?
Justin,
Just a quick note here to say, as others have done, thank you so much for your efforts in creating this remix.
I’ve just concluded an 18 month long campaign, about 95 hours of gameplay, using your remix, and me and my players had an absolute blast.
It speaks volumes about your design of the end game revelations that my players were able to get huge satisfaction about deducing these (in part or in full) themselves, without much DM-led input at all. It all felt natural, satisfying and narratively compelling – huge improvements on the suggested revelations in the published adventure!
Not to mention your prop packets, dioramas, etc which all added so much to the game and inspired me to go on and continue creating content tailored to my game.
An absolutely fantastic experience – thanks to the time and love invested in this project! I am sure it will continue to bring groups joy long after your original play through. I will find a way to chuck you some cash on your Patreon to say thanks!
[…] Puedes comprar el libro de campaña de Mentiras Eternas o la caja de campaña de Mentiras Eternas o El Rastro de Cthulhu. Echa un vistazo a Eternal Lies – The Alexandrian Remix […]
[…] Puedes comprar el libro de campaña de Mentiras Eternas o la caja de campaña de Mentiras Eternas o El Rastro de Cthulhu. Echa un vistazo a Eternal Lies – The Alexandrian Remix […]
[…] mi experiencia dirigiendo Mentiras Eternas esperaba encontrar algo similar al enorme trabajo de The Alexandrian, del que fusilé ideas y ayudas para la campaña sin ningún tipo de rubor. En este caso no […]
[…] mi experiencia dirigiendo Mentiras Eternas esperaba encontrar algo similar al enorme trabajo de The Alexandrian, del que fusilé ideas y ayudas para la campaña sin ningún tipo de rubor. En este caso no […]
[…] Puedes comprar el libro de campaña de Mentiras Eternas o la caja de campaña de Mentiras Eternas o El Rastro de Cthulhu. Echa un vistazo a Eternal Lies – The Alexandrian Remix […]
[…] Puedes comprar el libro de campaña de Mentiras Eternas o la caja de campaña de Mentiras Eternas o El Rastro de Cthulhu. Echa un vistazo a Eternal Lies – The Alexandrian Remix […]
[…] you automatically lose sanity as soon as you read a tome. However, I am running a version of the Alexandrian Remix of Eternal Lies adapted to Call of Cthulhu. (Players, DO NOT click that link.) In this remix, the characters are […]
I wonder if the dates were changed from 1934 to 1937 to allow for Transatlantic flights? I noted the mention of the DC-3 in the campaign overview and I knew that they first flew in 1936. That sent me down the rabbit-hole of transatlantic flight, which I found only started in 1937 for commercial passenger flights. There were some mail flights operating before this so there might be some fun roleplaying in the PCs trying to blag their way on to one of those…
[…] Eternal Lies – The Alexandrian Remix […]
Hi! I am running a version of Eternal Lies based on the Alexandrian Remix, and crossposting the logs to a freeform RP site I participate in. I thought you might enjoy getting a chance to see what other people are doing with your material!
[…] Eternal Lies – The Alexandrian Remix […]
[…] Eternal Lies – The Alexandrian Remix https://site.pelgranepress.com/index.php/eternal-lies/ […]
[…] Eternal Lies – The Alexandrian Remix https://site.pelgranepress.com/index.php/eternal-lies/ […]
[…] Eternal Lies – The Alexandrian Remix […]
This remix was very valuable for me when I first run this campaign in the years 2015-2017. Actually this remix came out while I was running the campaign, adding help in real time.
I read elsewhere that you’re on a second run of this masterpiece. Any news about that? Finished? Opinions? More improvement to the remix?
@Ricardo: My second run of the campaign was going well, but sadly got killed off by COVID. 🙁
Hey there! I’m getting ready to run this campaign, but I was wondering if you had a list of the physical props? I’ve got a 3d printer I could give them a go on. Thanks!
[…] de The Alexandrian, blog de referencia y el que considero el mejor portal de rol de la red. Su colección de ayudas para la mítica campaña para El Rastro de Cthulhu, Mentiras Eternas, sus cientos de entradas sobre […]