The Alexandrian

Design Notes: Scenario Tools

January 8th, 2020

The much delayed Welcome to the Island, a collection of four scenarios for Over the Edge, will be releasing later this month. If you’re looking for scenarios that embody the design principles I talk about here on the Alexandrian, then this is the book you’ve been waiting for. Jonathan Tweet and IOver the Edge: Welcome to the Island have collaborated on a scenario built around the party-planning game structure. The rest of the team, many of whom I originally recruited for Infinity, have created some really fantastic adventures featuring revelation lists, node-based scenario design, and a lot more cool stuff.

Welcome to the Island also features a small selection of what I now refer to as “scenario tools.” I first started developing these back around 2000 or 2001, early in my freelancing career, and have been slowly refining and adding to them ever since. If you’re just prepping notes for your home campaign, these are not things that you’d need (or want) to include. But published scenarios, they help bridge the gap between the author’s imagination and your gaming table. This often takes the form of giving you the tools to integrate a published scenario into your campaign: As writers there’s nothing we can do to avoid making a published adventure generic, but we can make it easier for you to take our generic plug-‘n-play module and make it a seamless part of what you and your players are creating.

These tools usually appear in sidebars. This intentionally segregates them from the main text of the scenario so that they don’t muddy up the presentation of the essential information you need at the table.

GROUNDWORK

Groundwork sidebars are used in scenarios to give examples of how a GM can incorporate elements of the scenario into their campaign prior to running the scenario. The idea is that you can make the scenario feel like an organic part of your campaign by properly laying the Groundwork for it.

We tend not to include anything that’s blatantly obvious. For example, you don’t need us to say something like, “This adventure features NPCs. You could have one of them show up before the adventure begins!” (Unless we have a particularly clever or relevant example of how that might work.)

SCENARIO THREADS

Scenario threads are the mirror image of Groundwork sidebars, suggesting ways in which elements of the scenario could be revisited in later scenarios.

In your home campaign, of course, this is something you should be doing organically: Pay attention to the people or places that particularly resonated with your players. If something interests them or is clicking for them, finding ways to reincorporate it into the campaign is an almost guaranteed success.

PLAYTEST TIP

By the time you’ve finished running a scenario, you’ll often have learned a lot about how you could have used it better. Some of these lessons can be applied in future scenarios, but it’s rare for a GM to have an opportunity to run the same scenario a second time. In published scenarios, though, we have the opportunity to share the insights we’ve gained during out playtests. These Playtest Tips are the “best practices” and offer suggestions for how particular encounters can be handled, alert you to potential problem areas, and try to provide other insights gleaned from our playtesting.

INTERSECTION

This is the newest addition my scenario toolkit and one that I picked up from previous editions of Over the Edge. Intersections reference other published scenarios and suggest how the material in that scenario could be tied to the material in this one. (For example, there’s a strange paranormal gadget in one scenario and a mad scientist in another scenario. When describing the mad scientist’s laboratory, we might include an Intersection that points out you could include a prototype or design notes for the paranormal gadget here, suggesting that this mad scientist was the one who developed it in the first place.)

For Welcome to the Island, these Intersections are limited to other scenarios in the same book. But future anthologies can include references between books, too.

FINAL THOUGHTS

The description of scenario tools in Welcome to the Island also includes revelation lists, which have been discussed here on the Alexandrian as part of the Three Clue Rule. I’d have included adversary rosters, too, but they aren’t used for any of the scenarios in this book. This material, along with the other tools described above, will be repeated in future adventure anthologies for Over the Edge because they weren’t included in the core rulebook. You can contrast this approach with Infinity, where I made sure these tools were described in the core rulebook specifically so that I wouldn’t have to explain them in every adventure we wanted to use them in.

(Which would be all of them, because they’re useful tools.)

I encourage other authors and publishers to also make use of these tools when writing scenarios for publication. They’re incredibly useful and I don’t feel like they should be put in a lockbox.

And if you have any suggestions for other useful tools I could be including in my published scenarios that would make them more useful for you to use at home, please let me know!

2 Responses to “Design Notes: Scenario Tools”

  1. Vagabundork says:

    ‘Intersection’ sounds like a good tool. In the case of Over the Edge, when we backed the Kickstarted, we were rewarded with plenty of material from previous editions, so I think it would be very useful if there were some intersection between they new and the old material, as well as tips or suggestions to convert old into new.

    Thanks

  2. Justin Alexander says:

    I considered that, but because the universe was “rebooted”, the material would also need mechanical adaptation, and the older books are limited in their availability (other than PDFs), we found that including such intersections was more confusing than useful.

    There are some definite easter eggs in WttI, though, tapping into the cool stuff from previous editions.

    I’ve also considered doing a blog entry or series on adapting the older material to the new edition. Mechanically it’s so trivial as to be almost meaningless, but the Island is ever-shifting.

Leave a Reply

Archives

Recent Posts


Recent Comments

Copyright © The Alexandrian. All rights reserved.