The Alexandrian

The Crystal Shard - R.A. SalvatoreR.A. Salvatore has two strengths as a writer. First, he’s capable of writing fresh, detailed, and exciting battle scenes – battle scenes which not only serve as really excellent set pieces, but which also actively contribute to the plot. Salvatore’s stories don’t get put on pause while his characters throw down. Instead, each fight is an important part of the evolving drama.

Salvatore’s second strength is his ability to craft epic, rapid-fire plots, cramming them full of the action scenes he writes so well, and then moving the whole package along at a fast clip. He keeps you entertained on every page.

For example, The Crystal Shard, the first novel in the Icewind Dale Trilogy, stretches across half a decade. It starts with a barbarian invasion, moves through a well-done coming-of-age story, and then concludes with a massive military campaign against the armies of an evil sorcerer. It includes dragon-slaying, demonic machinations, and barbarian heroes becoming kings.

That’s a lot of stuff to cram into 300 pages or so.

And Salvatore doesn’t slow down. In the second novel, Streams of Silver, you’ll find a deadly assassin bent on vengeance, a beautiful elven queen, a quest to reclaim a dwarven city lost to an ancient evil, a circle of evil wizards plotting for power, bar-room brawls, back alley dealings, and (of course) more dragon-slaying.

And in the third volume, The Halfling’s Gem, the trend continues: Desert intrigues, damsels in distress, wererat thieves, battles with pirates, an epic duel between the two greatest swordsmen in the world, and a portal to hell.

Streams of Silver - R.A. SalvatoreSalvatore’s narrative palette, as you can see, is drawn straight from stock fantasy and adventure fiction. His prose (except for his exceptional battle sequences) is purely pedestrian and frequently marred by his penchant for repeating the same piece of information (just in case you weren’t paying attention the first time he said it, I suppose). But what makes Salvatore’s stuff fun to read is his ability to reach a critical mass of sheer niftiness.

And that’s an important word: FUN.

If you’re looking for the next Great Fantasy Novel that will touch your soul and live unmarred in the book and volume of your mind, this isn’t it. But if you’re looking for some serious fun — the type of fun that used to be found in the best pulp fiction – then you can’t go too far wrong by grabbing some Salvatore.

There are a couple of other qualities which make the Icewind Dale Trilogy worth your while:

First, it feels like a really good D&D campaign. And I mean that in the best possible way. I don’t mean that you can see the dice being rolled or anything like that. Rather, I mean that the main characters have that rare sense of camaraderie, witty repartee, and ineffable chemistry that can be achieved when a gaming group really gets into the groove. They feel like the Three Musketeers. Again, it’s fun. (Just in case you weren’t paying attention the first time I said that.)

And, speaking of characters, they’re another highlight of the trilogy. The supporting cast is a bit cardboardy, but the main characters are a memorable and entertaining bunch: Each has a unique voice and personality. Each is given a distinct and interesting backstory. Each is developed in detail, with meaningful growth and change.

In this last regard, Salvatore shows a remarkable degree of skill when it comes to putting his characters into crucibles which serve to not only actively reveal but also change their quality.

Perhaps the most notable of Salvatore’s characters is Drizzt Do’Urden, a dark elf. Although the dark elves are known for their cruelty and evil, Drizzt is possessed of a noble heart. An exile from the great underground cities of his people, Drizzt is also an outcast in the surface world he has chosen as his home — perpetually judged by the color of his skin.

The Halfling's Gem - R.A. SalvatoreDrizzt is notable because he’s probably the first swords-and-sorcery hero of significance – cut from the same cloth as Conan, Elric, or the Gray Mouser – to appear since Karl Edward Wagner’s Kane stories in the 1970s. (His status as an outcast seems to draw frequent comparison to Elric, although that’s pretty much where the comparison comes to an end.)

In the narrative of the Icewind Dale Trilogy, Drizzt is on an equal footing with the rest of the main cast. But something about the character simply resonated with the readers. Personally, if I had to take a guess at what caused Drizzt’s immense and inordinate popularity, I would point my finger at Salvatore’s inspired decision to not only make Drizzt the finest swordsman in all the land, but to simultaneously give him a villainous rival of equal skill and ability. Conan, Cyrano, and the Gray Mouser are all clearly swordsmen of legendary prowess and skill… but only Drizzt, after being similarly pumped up in the expectations of the readers, gets to demonstrate his skill in a life-or-death duel with a villain of equal talent in the form of Artemis Entreri.

(For the record, Cyrano de Bergerac is still the finest swordsmen in all the many worlds. Leiber is an idle boaster.)

Drizzt’s popularity lead to a prequel trilogy dedicated to the telling of his personal history. And from that point on, he became the main character of the series (which is now referred to collectively as “The Legend of Drizzt”).

GRADES:

THE CRYSTAL SHARD: C+
STREAMS OF SILVER: C+
THE HALFLING’S GEM: C

R.A. Salvatore
Published: 1988 / 1989 / 1990
Publisher: Wizards of the Coast
Cover Price: $19.95 (Collected Edition)
ISBN: 078691811X

Share on TumblrTweet about this on TwitterShare on StumbleUponShare on FacebookShare on RedditShare on Google+Digg this

One Response to “What I’m Reading #54 – The Icewind Dale Trilogy”

  1. Justin Alexander says:

    ARCHIVED HALOSCAN COMMENTS

    Justin Alexander
    It’s the Demon Wars Trilogy I’m particularly interested in — the stuff he wrote without any corporate overseers.
    Wednesday, November 12, 2008, 1:26:46 AM


    Draz
    Vector Prime, I actually didn’t like at all. Enough that it actually got me to stop following Star Wars books thereafter entirely.

    My brother says The Highwayman is really good, though. And Salvatore himself thinks his Demon Wars Trilogy is his best work. (I haven’t actually read either of these.)
    Monday, November 10, 2008, 6:26:04 PM


    Mortegro
    Example of non-D&D stuff Salvatore has written: Vector Prime. I own this Star Wars novel, but it makes me cry inside now to think of where Lucas allowed the Extended Universe to go after the peace treaty between the New Republic and the Empire. I think I’ll stop talking about this now before I have a breakdown over the state of Star Wars.
    Sunday, November 09, 2008, 6:05:31 PM


    Justin Alexander
    The first novel in the Dark Elf trilogy is actually very good (I would give it a grade of B-). The other two are also quite good, although the second suffers somewhat by degenerating into narrating the Underdark Random Encounter Tables in certain places and the third novel suffers a little bit from prequel-itis (when the only motivation for certain actions appears to be “because that’s what needs to happen before the book I already wrote”) and repetitiveness.

    But, as you say, the trilogy is very solid and the place where is his skill and enthusiasm are equally matched.

    I keep meaning to try some of his non-TSR/WotC stuff and see if it’s any better than what the Drizzt novels degenerated into. (I’ll be posting more thoughts on the next trilogy of books in a day or so.)
    Friday, November 07, 2008, 6:35:39 PM


    Draz
    It’s worth noting that his prose got a lot better after this, his first trilogy.

    … But then his plots started to get stale, gradually, as he started writing books because WotC told him to (as a money farm), rather than because he actually felt there was a lot more of Drizzt’s story to be told.

    IMHO the prequel Drizzt trilogy are the best in-between ground, where his skill as an experienced writer and his enthusiasm as a new writer were both present.

    Admittedly I’ve read very little of his non-Drizzt books, though.
    Friday, November 07, 2008, 6:03:50 PM


    “John Lee”
    I’d have to agree with all this. R.A. Salvatore has bland prose, almost to the point that I’d call him a bad writer, but his books are great. Quite fun, good timesinks, and the bland writing falls away quickly as the fast-paced plot charges onward. I’d really say that it captures at least part of the essence of Dungeons and Dragons.
    Friday, November 07, 2008, 8:40:20 AM

Leave a Reply

Archives

Twitter

Recent Posts


Recent Comments