The Alexandrian

X-Men: First Class

June 7th, 2011

X-Men: First ClassA couple years ago, I reviewed the disastrously bad X-Men Origins: Wolverine. I concluded by saying that, unless they got Bryan Singer back, I wouldn’t be fooled into seeing another of these movies.

Executive Producer Bryan Singer

Story by Bryan Singer

… well played 20th Century Fox.

The previews also looked good, but I still waited for the reviews. And when the reviews came back positive (the film is currently reviewing better than Thor on Metacritic, and I thought Thor was a pretty good flick) I decided to take the risk.

And I’m really glad that I did.

Not only is X-Men: First Class better than X-Men Origins: Wolverine (a very low hurdle to clear), I think it may be the best X-Men movie they’ve made. It’s not perfect. But it is very, very good and I recommend checking it out. (Particularly if the only reason you’ve been holding back is because, like me, you were so bitterly disappointed by X3 and Wolverine.)

So, in my opinion, that’s two good comic book movies out of two so far this year. And I’ve got my fingers crossed for both Captain America (which looks great in the trailers) and Green Lantern (which will either be amazing or painful).

(Tangentially, I’ve seen a lot of industry “experts” claiming that X-Men: First Class is having a poor box office turn-out because Wolverine isn’t in it. Well… no. It’s having a poor box office turn-out because the last two movies in the franchise sucked and sucked hard. You can’t just bounce back from that. I think the only way they could have avoided a poor opening weekend for this movie would have been to get Bryan Singer back in the director’s chair and prominently advertise that fact. Frankly, I’m surprised they weren’t plastering Singer’s name all over the previews. I had to go digging to find out he was re-involved in the franchise. It would have sent a very clear “sorry about the last two films, please give us another chance” message to the audience.)

Share on TumblrTweet about this on TwitterShare on StumbleUponShare on FacebookShare on RedditShare on Google+Digg this

7 Responses to “X-Men: First Class”

  1. John K says:

    You’re much more forgiving than I am. I wouldn’t watch it for free. After the disappointments (that is to say, childhood nostalgia destroyers) of the last two X-men, Spiderman 2 and 3, all the Transformers, and others, it would take a miracle to get me into another comic book / cartoon movie theater seat.

    Nice Fifth Element reference, btw.

  2. Predrag says:

    Well, you are missing out on an excellent film…subdue your nerdrage and enjoy.

  3. John K says:

    Boycotting a movie genre that has consistently been a disappointment (understatement) is hardly nerdrage. When (if) the number of quality comic movies reaches an amount where I can ever again say, “Comic movies are generally ok,” I may go back and watch a few that I missed. Until then, I’m gonna sit back and watch Netflix and save my money.

  4. Justin Alexander says:

    90% of everything is crap. If you applied a standard of “the majority of films in this genre suck” to every genre of film and television, you would never watch anything at all.

    I mean, I agree 100% with your list of bad films. I just can’t follow the logic of the conclusion.

  5. John K says:

    That’s ok, there is none. :)

    I just go to the movies about once a year, and this one won’t be it.

  6. John K says:

    You know, you’d probably really like Sherlock. It’s a modern retelling. Sounds a bit corny but it’s actually amazing.

  7. Mournblade94 says:

    Well as per your last paragraph I am an example of the last few sucky movies hurting sales. Normally with Comic book movies I go opening weekend. I did not feel enthusiastic enough to go see it yet. I will go see it, possibly this weekend.

    Still I am sure there are many more like me that normally would have contributed to opening night sales.

Leave a Reply



Recent Posts

Recent Comments