The first term
which springs to mind in considering Cherryh’s DOWNBELOW
STATION is “military SF”. But, somehow, that doesn’t seem
adequate. When I think of military SF visions of Weber’s Honor
Harrington or Moon’s Heris Serrano dance before my eyes. And
comparing Honor Harrington to DOWNBELOW STATION is like
comparing a table knife to a machete: It may be technically
correct, but it is more than lacking in its descriptive
accuracy.
DOWNBELOW is a
war story. Not a story of the glorified war seen at a Saturday
matinee, bur rather the story of a war seen through the eyes of
an Anne Frank or a Vietnam vet. It is a war brutal, savage, and
viciously capricious. Indeed, Cherryh’s vision of future war
is, if anything, more horrific than anything the modern world
has seen: It is a thing of vacuum and hapless impotence.
The best
comparison I can draw to DOWNBELOW STATION would be Haldeman’s
FOREVER WAR. But Haldeman’s masterpiece pales in comparison to
the rich textures of Cherryh’s classic: Where Haldeman’s
message is a relatively simple, Vietnam parable, Cherryh weaves
an elaborate tapestry of motive, judgment, and consideration. As
a result, by the end of the book, I certainly know what my own
opinions on the war are – but I rather suspect that others
will draw completely dissimilar conclusions. Cherryh conjures a
stark, appalling *reality*: Complex, textured, and detailed.
Attempting to grasp what she has created is like trying to come
to grips with Beirut or Iraq – it has that kind of startling
depth.
The other work
which I invariably found myself thinking of while reading
DOWNBELOW STATION was CYTEEN, the only other work by Cherryh
which I have read to date. DOWNBELOW STATION, being the earlier
work, is almost inevitably a little cruder than CYTEEN, but many
of the same strengths are to be found here: Most notably,
Cherryh’s ability to fully realize the characters on all sides
of a conflict. Unlike CYTEEN, the effect is not quite perfect:
Characters like Lukas and Mazian may be given some depth, but
they’re still palpably the unmitigated villains of the piece,
while, on the other hand, the Konstantins are the sainted
heroes. In other places, though, Cherryh’s future gift for
characterization shines through – Signy, Elene, Satin, Josh,
Kressich – and it is in these places, naturally, that the work
finds its greatest resonance and most meaningful facets.
One thing I find
particularly interesting is Cherryh’s prose. When I begin a
Cherryh novel, I will often find myself noticing its distinctive
style. It seems to stand out in a way that I can’t quite put
my finger on: Perhaps it is an unusual word choice. Or a way of
structuring sentences and paragraphs. It’s difficult to
describe. But within a handful of pages, I find that I have
adjusted to it completely – at which point it becomes a
powerful storytelling tool, wielded by a master of her craft.
In short, I found DOWNBELOW STATION to be a powerful
and moving experience. Between this and CYTEEN, I am now
officially a Cherryh fanatic.
GRADE: A+ |